Decision time

8 January 2012

Remember that Estonian shawl I’ve been working on for months? Back in November, I estimated that I could knit 15 or 16 vertical repeats of the main pattern before I had to start on the edging. Well, I’m just shy of 15 repeats. And updated estimates – achieved with scale, calculator, and conservative guesswork – reveal it’s high time to get going on the edging.

unblocked lace looks so sad, doesn’t it?

The question is, do I want to go the traditional route, knitting the edging in two pieces from the outside in before sewing it all together? Or do I want to go the modern route, picking up stitches and knitting the edging from the inside out?

Normally, I’m not a slave to tradition. (Somebody refresh my memory: Who said, “We do not honor tradition by slavishly repeating it”? Anna Zilboorg, I think.) Normally, I’m all in favor of seamless methods.

But this time I’m thinking of going the traditional route, just for the sake of trying it out. I don’t think the sewing up will be that onerous. Actually, I tried it out this afternoon, on a couple swatches. (Hooray for swatches!) Weave a tail through a selvedge loop on the swatch of the main pattern, then weave it through a bind-off loop on the edging swatch, repeat, repeat, repeat, and voilà! You get a lacy and reasonably attractive join.

looks okay to me

Alright, so it seems I’ve decided on the traditional route. Now it’s just a matter of gathering the strength to cast on and establish pattern over roughly 500 stitches... twice; once for each section of edging. Wish me luck!

Tagged: swatching, lace, WIP.

It really does look nice the traditional way but...I don't think I could ever gather enough strength to attempt it. I have a skein of that same yarn and I know how cobwebby it is. I'm rooting for you, JC! That will be one gorgeous shawl.

» AnnP

Better you than me, looks beautiful though. Will it go to Mom upon completion ? You know she will beg if she sees it.

» Dolores

Sheesh. Are you two trying to psych me out?

Dolores, this is precisely why my mom does not get to see everything I make.

» JC